Which of these would be a good bike for a beginner?

To reply to the answer before me, yes the rebel is a great bike good for beginners but it is small and the excitement can die very quickly. The rebel is only a 250cc motorcycle. So he could ride for a few months then not really want it anymore, and being a bigger person that bike only gets slower. I realize he probably doesn't want to go drag racing with the Harley boys but you do want something that can hold up to traffic.